New AI tools are transforming architectural education, design and planning as we know it. So, does it even make sense to invest time in building your hand drawing skills anymore? After all, tools like Midjourney and Adobe Firefly can generate a concept design with a single prompt and a click of a button.
This discussion is hardly new: CAD was once thought to upend the need to draw by hand, too. But fast-forward decades, and you’ll find that architecture students continue to learn hand drawing as part of their curricula.
Let’s make the case for fostering hand-drawing skills in the age of generative AI – and finding time for it with the help of an essay writer professional if necessary.
A Quick History of the Architect’s Toolkit
Before there was computer-aided design (CAD), architects and designers had to rely mostly on their pencils and paper.
Of course, there were certain physical tools to facilitate project drawings, such as T-squares and set squares. Still, the process was quite time-consuming and required a whole set of skills. On top of that, even a tiny mistake or a change to the requirements could easily require redrawing the whole thing.
Enter CAD. Invented in the 1960s by French carmakers Renault and Citroen (and, perhaps, Boeing), CAD was pioneered by the automotive and aerospace industries. However, it didn’t take off in architecture and design until the 1980s and 1990s, when CAD tools (and computers in general) became more affordable and user-friendly.
It wouldn’t be egregious to call the adoption of CAD a revolution in architecture. CAD software streamlined the design process, facilitated the iterative approach to the project, and improved collaboration. Besides saving time and effort, modern CAD systems also enhance project visualization with their 3D design and rendering capabilities.
Today, if you study architecture and design, you’re likely to study the tenets of both 2D and 3D design, along with tools like AutoCAD, ArchiCAD, Revit, and Rhino.
Why Hand Drawing Isn’t Going Anywhere in Architectural Education
CAD software has been around for decades, but it hasn’t made hand drawing obsolete. Just ask any architecture and design student today whether they have to learn the ins and outs of hand drawing, and they’ll say ‘yes.’
So, why has hand drawing persisted as a crucial skill for architects and designers? Here are three possible answers.
Driving Creativity
“But CAD and generative AI can also be a part of the creative, collaborative process!” you may scoff here. Yet, as many practicing architects and designers point out, it’s easier to get an idea to the paper than to a user interface – especially if it’s not fully fleshed out yet.As SHP’s project architect Mike Bednar put it, the connection between “your brain, your hand, and a pen […] allows ideas to flow easily and flourish.” James Wines dubbed this idea the Mind to Hand theory.
Facilitating Communication and Collaboration
Sketches tend to be looser and less detailed than digital renderings designed in CAD software. So, you can quickly communicate your ideas to the client or fellow architects or designers, all without spending hours fleshing out every detail in CAD software.
That’s why sketching remains the go-to tool for brainstorming concept designs and even master planning projects. Plus, as counterintuitive as it may sound, sketching an idea quickly can often be faster than creating a digital rendering of the same idea.
Capturing Your Ideas for Later
As design is a creative process, it’s not linear by nature. At some point in the project, you may need to return to the proverbial drawing board and tinker with other ideas. Sketching those initial ideas early on helps you preserve them for later so that you don’t have to start completely from zero.
Hand Drawing Doesn’t Need to Happen on Paper
If you’re not one to think yourself capable of drawing, you’re not alone. Take the story of Farhad Manjoo: in his New York Times opinion column, he admitted that he’d always been failing at learning to draw despite his immense desire to develop the skill.
After years of trial and error, he finally managed to overcome the frustration of failures with the help of an iPad and Procreate, a digital drawing and painting app.
This is just one story that illustrates a potential shift toward digital drawing. Thanks to the magic of the Undo button, you can speed up sketching even further while letting your creative juices flow.
Where Will AI Take Us?
Of course, architecture and design aren’t invincible to the AI boom that other industries are experiencing. Midjourney and Adobe Firefly are already being used to generate concept design, while tools like Maket can produce design alternatives in an instant.
AI-powered tools designed specifically for architects and designers have also entered the stage, such as:
- ARCHITEChTURES for residential planning
- BricsCAD for building information modeling
- ARK for schematic design
- Sidewalk Labs for urban planning
However, much like the CAD boom, the proliferation of AI tools doesn’t mean it’s game over for hand drawing. For one, generative AI models are limited by their training datasets. To put it simply, Adobe Firefly can’t generate something 100% unique and never-before-seen; it can only replicate or mix visuals it was trained on.
On top of that, there are certain ethical considerations for using generative AI tools. For example, training datasets may contain intellectual property and copyrighted materials. Some AI models may also expose sensitive data from your inputs to other users.
That said, AI tools are likely to enter the curriculum anyway – and some graduate design studios already use them. For example, students at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign School of Architecture learned to use AI to design affordable housing at scale in the fall of 2024.Much like CAD software, AI tools can speed up tasks that take too much time today, such as refining building envelopes for massive models or optimizing floor plan unit layout variations. A few decades from now, they’ll probably become another tool in the architect’s toolbox, along with CAD – and hand drawing.
Final Thoughts
If you’re an architecture student and you wonder whether learning to draw by hand is worth the effort, the answer is a resounding ‘yes.’ No matter how advanced AI tools become, they won’t be able to substitute the smooth flow of ideas from your mind to the paper (or a tablet, if you prefer having the Undo option at all times).
Leave a comment